Instagram Reels vs Posts: Engagement and Reach Comparison 20
Learn how Instagram Reels and Posts differ in reach and engagement, plus strategies to combine them for maximum audience growth in 2024.
Introduction: Understanding Reels vs Posts on Instagram
When it comes to Instagram marketing, one of the most debated topics is Reels vs Post Instagram strategies. With Instagram competing against TikTok, Reels have emerged as a major content format—short, engaging videos designed for virality. In contrast, feed posts (both image carousels and videos) continue to anchor profiles with polished, enduring content.
Choosing between Reels and Posts is not just about content style—it directly impacts reach, engagement, and brand growth. The right mix can skyrocket your visibility and help you create a sustainable, loyal audience base.
In this article, you’ll learn the core differences between Instagram Reels and Posts, see how each performs in terms of metrics, and discover proven strategies to blend them effectively for maximum impact in 2024.
---
Key Differences Between Instagram Reels and Feed Posts
Although both formats exist within the same platform, Instagram Reels and feed Posts are fundamentally different in format, placement, and algorithmic treatment.
Format and Presentation
- Reels: Vertical video (9:16 aspect ratio), up to 90 seconds (sometimes longer for select users), displayed in the dedicated Reels feed, Explore Tab, and user feeds.
- Posts: Can be single images, carousels, or videos (landscape, square, or portrait); appear in the profile grid and followers’ home feeds.
Algorithmic Reach
Reels are designed to push content beyond your followers, using AI-driven recommendations similar to TikTok’s For You Page. Posts, however, primarily serve your existing audience, with organic reach relying more on engagement signals from followers.
Content Lifespan
- Reels: Can gain traction days or weeks after posting due to algorithmic resurfacing.
- Posts: Typically peak in impressions within the first 24–48 hours.
---
Performance Metrics: Reels vs Posts
From a data standpoint, performance varies, with Reels excelling at discovery and Posts strengthening community engagement.
Common Metrics to Track
- Views (Reels) or Impressions (Posts)
- Engagement Rate (likes, comments, shares ÷ reach)
- Shares & Saves
- Follower Growth Attributed to Content
Observations From 2023–2024 Data
- Reels often deliver 2–3× more reach to non-followers compared to Posts.
- Posts tend to maintain higher engagement rates per impression with an existing audience.
- Saves are more common on valuable carousel or informational posts, while shares thrive on entertaining Reels.
---
When to Use Instagram Reels
Reels shine when you want:
- Trend Participation: Using trending sounds, challenges, or memes.
- Discoverability: Appearing in Explore and Reels tabs to reach non-followers.
- Viral Potential: With engaging hooks and share-worthy content, Reels can spread rapidly.
- Showcasing Motion: Tutorials, behind-the-scenes clips, lifestyle snippets, or transformations.
Reels are ideal for top-of-funnel awareness—introducing new audiences to your profile.
---
When to Use Instagram Posts
Feed posts remain important because they:
- Strengthen Branding: Well-composed images and carousels reflect brand identity.
- Enable Detailed Captions: Suitable for storytelling, educational content, or announcements.
- Provide a Permanent Portfolio: Living in your profile grid, posts are easier to revisit.
- Support Long-Term SEO: Posts can rank in Instagram’s keyword search better for evergreen information.
Use posts for mid-to-bottom funnel goals—converting followers into loyal customers or advocates.
---
Pros and Cons: Reels vs Posts
| Format | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Instagram Reels |
|
|
| Instagram Posts |
|
|
---
How the Algorithm Treats Reels vs Posts in 2024
Instagram’s 2024 algorithm update has further distinguished how Reels and Posts are distributed:
- Reels are shown to both followers and non-followers, with a heavy weight on watch time, replays, and shares.
- Posts are prioritized in followers’ feeds based on relationship strength (e.g., past engagement, DMs exchanged).
Instagram has also confirmed they are reducing the frequency of repeated Reels from the same creator to diversify user content, making originality more critical than ever.
---
Combining Reels and Posts for Optimal Engagement
A winning strategy doesn’t choose one over the other—it blends them:
- Use Reels to Attract: Hook new audiences with short, high-impact videos.
- Use Posts to Retain: Deliver depth, authority, and brand value in carousel posts or high-quality images.
- Cross-Promote: Share a Reel snippet that directs viewers to a detailed carousel post.
- Plan Themes: Apply content pillars to decide which topics fit better as Reels or Posts.
This ensures you cover both discovery and nurturing.
---
Real Examples from Brands and Influencers
Several brands have mastered this balanced approach:
- Sephora: Uses Reels for makeup tutorials with trending sounds; posts feature product shots with detailed captions.
- Gymshark: Shares motivational images and athlete spotlights as posts; produces workout Reels to boost virality.
- Travel Influencers: Post cinematic Reels to spark wanderlust, paired with feed posts containing detailed itineraries.
---
Actionable Tips to Test and Analyze Reels vs Posts Performance
Because audience preferences are niche-specific, testing and analysis are critical:
- Audit Content Monthly: Compare median reach of each format over a set period.
- Experiment with Timing: Publish at varied peak times to gauge format performance.
- Track Saves vs Shares: Valuable for understanding long-term vs short-term impact.
- Optimize Hooks: For Reels, the first 3 seconds matter most; for Posts, focus on the opening caption line.
- Use Insights: Review Instagram analytics to pinpoint which format drives more follows or sales.
---
Conclusion: Building a Balanced Content Mix
The Reels vs Post Instagram debate is less about crowning a winner and more about aligning formats with your marketing goals. Reels deliver rapid reach and growth, while Posts deepen connection and convey lasting brand messages.
By using both strategically—perhaps starting with 60% Reels for growth and 40% Posts for retention—you can fuel both discovery and loyalty. Track results, adjust ratios, and stay responsive to engagement trends.
Ready to elevate your Instagram strategy? Start experimenting with a balanced mix of Reels and Posts today to maximize visibility, engagement, and long-term brand success.
